GameSalad

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

First payment... big problem ??

beaudoin_nbeaudoin_n Posts: 184Member
edited November -1 in Introductions
Hi

I know that apple's daily/weekly stats should not be used for financial reports... but have you ever had such a difference that you start to wonder if you are not being ripped off ?

In one of my march weeks i sold to US 160 of one app and 106 of a second one... but yet my monthly total is 145 and 70 !!!!

What gives ?

Let me know your thoughts on this
«1

Comments

  • BarkBarkCoBarkBarkCo Posts: 1,400Member
    Could that be the 30% Apple keeps?
  • beaudoin_nbeaudoin_n Posts: 184Member
    no i am talking about the units sold count
  • StormyStudioStormyStudio United KingdomPosts: 3,987Member
    hmm...not great....get some deviation myself but not up to those numbers yet so it's hard to compare...
  • beaudoin_nbeaudoin_n Posts: 184Member
    anyone know the best way to contact them ?
  • butterbeanbutterbean Posts: 4,315Member, PRO
    I had some deviation in my payment schedule too versus my downloads, so I emailed them, I'll let you know what they say.... sketchy!

    I looked over the numbers again, and although it wasn't much of a discrepancy, it seems there still is some deviation from what I added up in downloads
  • ChaserChaser Posts: 1,453Member
    Refunds maybe????
  • beaudoin_nbeaudoin_n Posts: 184Member
    What refunds ???
  • rebumprebump Posts: 1,058Member
    Could it be returns??
  • rebumprebump Posts: 1,058Member
    Funny...I typed the above but I wanted to look at my stats before sending to double-check something...then hit sent and ended up after another "returns" entry. Oh well. :-)
  • CrazybreadmanCrazybreadman Posts: 674Member
    I cant match the pmt amount w/ appfigures no matter which way i turn it. Mine is a good $100 less than what appfigures came up with. I tried separating the monthly amount by country (only the USA) for March and the pmt txt is WAAAAY short. Then I tried doing it by month of release date to release date, which was the 23rd. Still doesn't match and is short of that. Also the prior amount that carried over was short. What gives? Now, appfigures gives you what you get after Apple takes their share so this shouldn't be the case. I guess the fiscal month that Apple comes up with doesn't match what Appfigures uses?
  • quantumsheepquantumsheep Posts: 8,188Member
    Are the totals from your apps all from one region? Maybe that's it?

    @crazybreadman - maybe contact the appfigures guys and see what they have to say about it?

    Dr. Sam Beckett never returned home...
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/Quantum_Sheep
    Web: http://www.quantum-sheep.com

  • YodapolloYodapollo Posts: 447Inactive
    Hey guys,

    My first thought is to double check to see if you have any returns and if any promo codes were used. The promo codes generally still count as purchases, but they probably won't show up on your payment statement, since they were given out for free.

    Another possibility could be purchases that haven't been "fully processed" yet.

    Still, we're looking into it and hopefully we'll have a more in-depth answer sometime in the next day or so.

    --Yodapollo
  • rebumprebump Posts: 1,058Member
    I don't use AppFigures but in your iTunesConnect daily/weekly reports, the developer provided promo code figures are broken out with a "Sale Price" of zero and "Product Type ID" of 7. These are different than some entries that have a price but then have a "GS" or "GP" (or "GR"?) in the "Promo Code" column (guessing those are for iTunes gift cards and such). Anyway, maybe AppFigures is including the developer provided promo code figures in your counts?
  • JamesZeppelinJamesZeppelin Posts: 1,927Member
    Returns do show up, i have seen a couple.
    But yes promo codes DO count on your units sold

    You are a month off also
    March's statement is for like a month before that even...
    my guess is you are seeing feb with a tiny bit of Jan prorated from layover.
    They send you he statement at the end of feb and call it march's payment date.
    It is almost three months ago by the time you get paid.

    Ironically when you buy something they have the money the next day

    I'd like to send them a bill for my ipads in three months
  • butterbeanbutterbean Posts: 4,315Member, PRO
    When I added up the units sold, I didn't count the promo codes given. Of course I wasn't using appfigures or another site, but rather itunes connect daily reports.

    When you look at itunes daily reports, you can tell which was promos used because there's a 0 amount next to royalty payment or something like that.

    I came up with an $11 dollar discrepancy, and emailed itunes banking about it, I'll let you know what they say :)
  • mrfunkleberrymrfunkleberry Posts: 424Member
    I seem to be out by about $130 from the US alone, this is ridiculous. There was a time in march where i was getting over 100 sales a day. All i got was a disappointing £200. Well on this basis, there's no way i can continue with GS. :( Well i may do an hour a week, nothing like what im doing now
  • BarkBarkCoBarkBarkCo Posts: 1,400Member
    Is this a GS problem, or a iPhone/iPad Developer program issue?
  • eboyeboy Posts: 239Member
    Oh man, I've only made $17. Waaa.
  • butterbeanbutterbean Posts: 4,315Member, PRO
    It's an Apple problem :)

    That's pretty steep MrFunkleberry, not cool!
  • butterbeanbutterbean Posts: 4,315Member, PRO
    http://www.intomobile.com/2009/03/25/apple-egregiously-dropping-the-ball-on-iphone-developer-payments-customer-service.html

    Read this article, it said that someone was shorted 10K in payment, so I guess this has been a known issue.

    I guess I can live without my $11 :)

    And look at this thread, looks like we're not the only ones having issues:

    http://www.iphonedevsdk.com/forum/business-legal-app-store/16182-itunes-payments-banking-please-stop-emailing-us.html
  • mrfunkleberrymrfunkleberry Posts: 424Member
    No no sorry. I got my dates wrong there isn't a $130 discrepancy its only $7. Okay you need about 100 sales a day, every day, to make some decent bread. Problem is to make a game of that quality it'll probably take me a whole year, i just ain't as talented as tshirtbooth. Oh well, enough of this moaning, i know i'm having far too much fun to quit.
  • butterbeanbutterbean Posts: 4,315Member, PRO
    Yea I had to recheck mine too MrFunkle and found out I was shorted a bit, not $100 like I originally thought. But I still emailed them anyway to get some info

    Don't give up! Tshirt has been there since the beginning so what would take months for someone to program a game takes him days, he's a talented guy!

    I find that doing multiple projects at a time helps break up the monotony, some are longer than others :)
  • mrfunkleberrymrfunkleberry Posts: 424Member
    Thanks butterbean. I'm okay, like i said, i'm having far too much fun.
  • quantumsheepquantumsheep Posts: 8,188Member
    mrfunkleberry said:
    Thanks butterbean. I'm okay, like i said, i'm having far too much fun.

    Yeah, your previous post really didn't sound like you at all!

    Is someone wearing your meatsuit?

    I'll buy you a pint on Saturday and all will be right with the world, don't you worry!

    QS ;)

    Dr. Sam Beckett never returned home...
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/Quantum_Sheep
    Web: http://www.quantum-sheep.com

  • butterbeanbutterbean Posts: 4,315Member, PRO
    That's good :) You are too much fun to not have in the forums MrFunkle! :)

    Here you go QS: Since I won't see you Saturday, this one's on me :)

    http://www.spirituosenworld.de/produkte/bitter/details/ramazzotti_sambuca_gr.jpg
  • mrfunkleberrymrfunkleberry Posts: 424Member
    Awww you guys! *sniff*
  • butterbeanbutterbean Posts: 4,315Member, PRO
    So I received a response from ITS banking and they basically said that sales reports and financial reports are different.

    Sales reports are good for getting a real time feel of how many downloads you may have but financial reports reflect the end result of transactions processed and billed to customers, so the two should not be compared.

    I still question it, but at least it clears things up. Not sure where the discrepancy might be coming from, but for me it wasn't a huge gap
  • JamesZeppelinJamesZeppelin Posts: 1,927Member
    yeah like i was saying its so far off....
    Getting paid for march sales is still a ways out.

    Can't get discouraged. A lot of self employed folks with a serious business spend or go into debt easily a hundred k or more as a startup investment.

    To be a few months into a business even see a dime of profit (meaning not in debt) is pretty remarkable.

    Look at education...It's the worst but, people dont think about it. My wife's education for example took nearly ten years and was over 200k. Those student loans won't let her technically see profit for 20 years. Sure she keeps some of her paycheck but none of the money is really ours. It's just all how you look at.

    This apple (and android) thing is really in unique in that aspect
  • beaudoin_nbeaudoin_n Posts: 184Member
    So I forgot to mention this has nothing to do with GS... simply a discrenpence between two iTunesconnect reports... i sent an email to itspayments, they asked me to send another to itsreports

    I'll see what they come up with !
  • synthesissynthesis Posts: 1,693Member
    @Mr. Funkleberry

    The app dev business is not much different from any other business...especially in tech. Its highly competitive...well saturated...and very fluid. Only the best survive.

    You seem to have lots of talent from what I have seen...but these days its not enough. You (as an entrepreneur) have to have the whole package. Business sense, salesmanship, rock solid determination, lots of trial and error, a massive tolerance for failure, and much more. If you are in it to make a living...you have to give it lots of time. I've been in self-employment for 10+ years and was profitable for maybe 2 of those years. its a roller-coaster ride...with lots of ups and downs...especially in economic times like these.

    But in my 10+ year history of searching for a good product business to be in (other than soliciting design services)...the Appstore is the first thing we have come across that requires virtually no up-front investment other than time...and on top of that...to have up to 100,000,000 consumers delivered to you by year's end at the low cost of 30cents on the dollar IN PROFITS...with virtually no up front costs to deliver a product is unrivaled ANYWHERE.

    This is amazing to us...that you can have direct consumer access for a product overnight and be able to sell a product with ZERO inventory expenses, distribution costs/concerns, middlemen, office overhead...etc. Its amazing to us and we plan to stick around for the long haul. We have been working for a year so far with only our first app series coming out this spring. Sales are slow out of the gate...but we believe in our concept and are giving it time. Plus...the great thing is you publish and forget about it and move on. In time...as your product line grows...so should your revenue.

    But again...its not easy and to make GOOD money at it...you have to stand out...which I have found is no different than anything else. its about sales and having a consistently good product that the general consumer wants. This is the cornerstone of capitalism. Its the same for everybody. Fortunately with something like the app store and GS...you don't need a lot of startup capital or resources to play and the risk to reward ratio is VERY tolerable...at least for us.

    Good luck...and I recommend sticking with it.
    -Syn

    www.spiritApps.com
This discussion has been closed.